Walmart Inc.

(New York Stock Exchange)
Back to all articles
Somewhat Bullish +50

Costco (COST) vs Walmart (WMT): Which is a Better Stock to Buy?

Company update AI-generated analysis

πŸ“ˆ Walmart's Sam's Club membership income grew approximately 11.3% in the quarter, outpacing Costco's 7.3% growth and compounding the specific revenue line that justifies Costco's premium valuation.

πŸ’° Walmart trades near forty times its past year's earnings compared to Costco's forty-five times, offering a lower entry multiple for investors seeking exposure to warehouse club growth.

πŸ“Š Costco reported fourth-quarter comparable sales growth of 9.4%, demonstrating that the business has not lost its grip on customers despite a slower membership fee expansion rate.

πŸ’‘ Walmart possesses a second high-margin profit engine in advertising and marketplace fees, which are growing far faster than shelf-based retail margins, unlike Costco's strategy.

πŸ“‰ A portion of Costco's earnings beat was derived from a one-off tariff refund of roughly $0.15 per share, meaning the organic performance beat was narrower than headline figures suggest.

πŸ† Costco maintains extraordinary operational strength with over 150 million cardholders and a worldwide renewal rate near 90%, though executive membership take-up growth has slowed to an all-time high but lower pace.

Bullish Signals
  • Walmart's Sam's Club membership income grew approximately 11.3% in the quarter, significantly outpacing Costco's 7.3% growth and effectively compounding the specific revenue line that drives Costco's valuation premium.
  • Walmart benefits from a second high-margin profit engine through advertising and marketplace fees, which are growing far faster than its traditional retail margins, providing a diversification advantage over Costco's single-line model.
  • Walmart trades at a more attractive multiple of approximately forty times earnings compared to Costco's forty-five times, offering better value for investors seeking exposure to the warehouse club sector.
Risk Factors
  • Investors previously questioned the quality of profit behind Walmart's growth, causing shares to fall sharply in August even after a quarter that beat expectations.
  • Walmart's broader growth strategy is more exposed to the ordinary consumer compared to Costco, potentially making it more vulnerable to economic downturns affecting discretionary spending.
Full Analysis
Walmart Inc. (NASDAQ: WMT) is analyzed as a compelling investment alternative to Costco Wholesale Corporation, primarily due to its superior growth in the membership segment that justifies Costco's valuation premium. While Costco reported fourth-quarter earnings of $6.75 per share with comparable sales rising 9.4%, much of this beat was driven by a non-recurring tariff refund of approximately $0.15 per share. Walmart's Sam's Club membership income grew at a faster pace than Costco's, rising roughly 11.3% compared to Costco's 7.3% growth in the same period. This accelerated growth in Walmart's core warehouse club business is viewed as compounding Costco's signature revenue line more effectively. Additionally, Walmart benefits from a second high-margin profit engine through advertising and marketplace fees, which are growing significantly faster than its traditional retail margins. Despite Costco maintaining strong operational metrics like a near 90% worldwide renewal rate and record executive membership take-up, the article concludes that Walmart is currently the better buy. The rationale rests on Walmart's ability to grow the specific line item that drives Costco's premium valuation while trading at a more attractive multiple of forty times earnings versus Costco's forty-five times earnings.