Walmart Inc.

(New York Stock Exchange)
Back to all articles
Slightly Bullish +25

Costco vs. Walmart: What's the Better Consumer Staples Buy Right Now?

AI-generated analysis

πŸ›’ Walmart and Costco are both major consumer staples giants, but Walmart has a wider omnichannel reach serving virtually every demographic.

πŸ’° Costco generates roughly 50% of its operating income from membership fees, which provide 2% of total revenue.

πŸ“Š In the latest quarter, Walmart reported $190.7 billion in revenue compared to Costco's $68.2 billion.

πŸ€– Walmart is leveraging its scale for high-margin non-retail businesses like digital advertising (Walmart Connect) and third-party marketplace sales.

πŸš€ While Costco is expanding digitally, Walmart's e-commerce and logistics growth are outpacing the retailer due to faster shipping options.

πŸ’΅ Both companies offer dividends, but Walmart is a "Dividend King" with 53 consecutive years of increases versus Costco's 22.

πŸ“ˆ Costco's dividend has grown significantly faster over the past five years (86%) compared to Walmart (35%).

πŸ€‘ As of late April, Walmart was trading at a lower valuation multiple (45.1x) than Costco (49.4x).

πŸ“‰ Walmart's stock has gained 33% in the last 12 months, while Costco's performance has been relatively flat during the same period.

🏒 Walmart operates Sam's Club as a membership-only competitor to Costco, whereas Costco focuses on bulk goods and selective selling.

🌍 By market cap, Walmart is the 11th-largest company globally (NASDAQ: WMT), ranking ahead of Costco's 26th position.

πŸ“‰ Both stocks are currently considered expensive by most valuation metrics and unlikely to show consistent double-digit revenue growth soon.

πŸ’Ό The article notes that while Walmart is recommended as a better buy right now, it was not included in the author team's top 10 stock picks for immediate buying.

⚠️ Investors are cautioned not to rely solely on one article's recommendation and should consider broader market performance benchmarks like the S&P 500.

Bullish Signals
  • Walmart has done an impressive job of expanding beyond traditional brick-and-mortar retail into high-margin areas like advertising and e-commerce.
  • In its latest quarter, Walmart reported $190.7 billion in revenue, demonstrating significant scale as the 11th-largest company in the world by market cap.
  • Walmart operates its membership-only Sam's Clubs to compete directly with Costco while maintaining its massive omnichannel reach and ability to serve every demographic.
  • Walmart has leveraged its massive traffic to grow high-margin non-retail businesses, including digital advertising via Walmart Connect and its third-party marketplace, Walmart Marketplace.
  • As of April 29, Walmart's stock was trading at 45.1 times projected earnings, making it a cheaper option with more momentum compared to Costco's flat performance and higher multiple.
  • Walmart has increased its quarterly dividend for 53 consecutive years, earning its status as a Dividend King and offering stability and consistency to investors.
  • Walmart's faster shipping speed and convenience have strengthened Walmart+'s appeal, potentially capturing customers who would otherwise choose Amazon Prime.
Risk Factors
  • Costco's stock is trading at a premium compared to Walmart, priced at 49.4 times projected earnings versus Walmart's 45.1 times.
  • Costco faces an inherent ceiling on revenue growth due to its smaller scale and inability to match Walmart's vast market cap ranking (26th vs. 11th largest globally).
  • Walmart has demonstrated superior digital transformation, gaining faster traction in e-commerce and high-margin non-retail areas like advertising and marketplace sales.
  • Costco's revenue diversification is limited as it relies heavily on membership fees (50% of operating income), whereas Walmart has successfully monetized data traffic and third-party services.
  • Investors seeking consistent stability may be exposed to higher risk at Costco, as its dividend growth rate (86% over five years) masks a longer track record of increases compared to Walmart's Dividend King status (53 consecutive years).
  • Despite recent momentum, Walmart stock is up 33% in the past 12 months while Costco has remained relatively flat, indicating weaker short-term price appreciation for Costco.
  • Walmart offers a higher dividend yield of approximately 0.7% compared to Costco's 0.5%, providing better cash flow potential for income-oriented investors.
Full Analysis
The article analyzes whether Walmart or Costco represents the better investment opportunity within the consumer staples sector as of late April and early May. The author ultimately recommends Walmart, citing its broader omnichannel strategy, significant non-retail growth areas, and lower valuation relative to Costco. While acknowledging that both companies are massive giants with strong shareholder returns over time, the piece highlights distinct operational differences: Costco's revenue is largely driven by membership fees generating high operating margins, whereas Walmart focuses on high-volume sales across a wider range of categories and customers. Key data points presented include Walmart's recent $190.7 billion in revenue compared to Costco's $68.2 billion. Regarding memberships, Costco holds 147.2 million cardholders with paid memberships up 4.8% year-over-year, contributing roughly half of its operating income. The comparison extends to stock valuation, showing Walmart trading at approximately 45x forward earnings versus Costco's 49x. Dividend analysis reveals Walmart as a Dividend King with 53 consecutive years of increases and a current yield near 0.7%, while Costco has a higher growth rate in its dividend over the last five years but a lower yield around 0.5%. The author argues that Walmart currently offers better momentum, having risen roughly 33% in the past 12 months compared to Costco's flat performance. The piece emphasizes Walmart's expansion into higher-margin sectors like digital advertising and e-commerce logistics, which positions it for long-term upside despite neither stock being considered cheap by traditional valuation metrics. The article concludes by referencing a specific Motley Fool Stock Advisor list that did not include Walmart, contrasting the current recommendation with that list's historical performance on stocks like Netflix and Nvidia to illustrate the potential for significant returns if an investor had followed those earlier picks.