Space Exploration Technologies Corp

(NASDAQ)
Back to all articles
Somewhat Bullish +45

'Lost in Space,' Says Top Investor About SpaceX Stock

Market commentary AI-generated analysis

πŸ“‰ SpaceX shares trade below their $135 IPO price despite a recent rebound, weighed down by political uncertainty following Democratic midterm victories.

πŸ’° The company trades at roughly 180x operating earnings based on Q3 income of $2.79 billion, requiring tenfold profit growth to match S&P 500 multiples.

πŸš€ Launch segment revenue grew only 2% year-over-year in the first nine months while swinging to an adjusted EBITDA loss.

πŸ“Ά Connectivity remains a bright spot with nine-month revenue up over 50% and operating income rising two-thirds.

🌐 The cellular push requires a ground network, facing established competition from AT&T, Verizon, T-Mobile, and Amazon's Leo project.

πŸ€– AI unit lost more than $3 billion over nine months despite $16.4 billion in third-quarter capital expenditure.

🧠 Grok ranks 43rd on LMArena text leaderboards against deep-pocketed rivals like OpenAI, Anthropic, Google, and Meta.

πŸ’» SpaceX lacks custom chips to control AI costs, unlike competitors Amazon and Google who utilize proprietary hardware.

πŸ“‰ Adjusted EBITDA metrics flatter the company by excluding stock-based compensation that dilutes shareholders.

βš–οΈ Analyst consensus is Strong Buy with 28 Buys and 5 Holds versus one analyst agreeing with a Strong Sell rating.

🎯 The average price target of $253.57 implies shares could gain 94% over the one-year timeframe.

πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡¦ Political risks persist as Musk ordered a slowdown of military Starlink service for Ukraine, leading to independent network deals.

Bullish Signals
  • Connectivity segment revenue increased by more than 50% year-over-year in the first nine months.
  • Operating income for the connectivity unit grew by approximately two-thirds during the same period.
  • The company recently beat Wall Street estimates on both the top and bottom lines for the third quarter.
  • Analyst consensus is overwhelmingly bullish with 28 Buys and 5 Holds compared to only one Strong Sell.
Risk Factors
  • The launch unit swung to an adjusted EBITDA loss, relying on Starlink connectivity to remain profitable.
  • AI unit lost more than $3 billion over nine months despite heavy investment of $16.4 billion in capex alone.
  • Grok ranks 43rd on LMArena text leaderboards against major competitors including OpenAI, Google, and Meta.
  • SpaceX lacks its own custom chips to keep AI costs down unlike Amazon and Google.
  • Adjusted EBITDA excludes stock-based compensation, a recurring cost that dilutes shareholders.
  • The company trades at roughly 180x earnings, requiring profits to grow tenfold to match S&P 500 multiples.
  • Political uncertainty following Democratic midterm victories clouds the outlook for a potential Tesla merger.
Full Analysis
SpaceX (NASDAQ:SPCX) shares have declined since its record-breaking IPO, trading below the $135 offering price despite a recent rebound. The stock faces headwinds from political uncertainty following Democratic midterm victories, which complicates prospects for a potential Tesla merger and regulatory support. Although the company recently beat Wall Street estimates on revenue and earnings for the third quarter, top investor The Value Portfolio argues that headline figures mask deeper structural challenges within the business. The investment thesis is heavily weighed down by valuation concerns and operational inefficiencies. Based on Q3 operating income of $2.79 billion, SpaceX trades at approximately 180x earnings, a multiple requiring nearly tenfold profit growth to align with S&P 500 standards. Capital spending remains aggressive at over $65 billion annually. The launch segment specifically struggled with only 2% year-over-year revenue growth in the first nine months and swung to an adjusted EBITDA loss, relying on Starlink connectivity to offset weakness. Growth prospects are tempered by intense competition and high costs in key segments. While connectivity revenue surged over 50%, the push into cellular requires a ground network that competitors like AT&T and Verizon already possess. The AI unit lost more than $3 billion over nine months despite $16.4 billion in capex, with Grok ranking 43rd on text leaderboards against rivals like OpenAI and Google. Additionally, SpaceX lacks custom chips to control costs, and adjusted EBITDA excludes significant stock-based compensation that dilutes shareholders. Analyst consensus remains overwhelmingly bullish despite the bearish outlook from The Value Portfolio. While one Street analyst agrees with the Strong Sell rating, 28 analysts rate the stock as a Buy and five as a Hold. The average price target of $253.57 implies a potential 94% gain over the next year. However, political risks regarding Ukraine's Starlink usage and the high valuation multiple present significant downside risks that investors must weigh against the strong buy consensus.