3M Company

(New York Stock Exchange)
Back to all articles
Slightly Bullish +25

A $1,000 Investment in These Former Dividend Aristocrats 10 Years Ago Is Worth How Much Today?

AI-generated analysis

πŸ“‰ AT&T turned a $1,000 investment into $1,598 over 10 years but significantly underperformed the S&P 500's 244% gain.

πŸ’° 3M grew a $1,000 investment to $1,435 over the same decade, also falling well short of the market index performance.

🏒 Both companies lost their status as "Dividend Aristocrats" following messy corporate breakups and strategic missteps.

πŸ“Ί AT&T's media expansion ended badly with a WarnerMedia spin-off in April 2022 that reduced its quarterly dividend by 46.6%.

πŸ§ͺ 3M faced a slower decline driven by Combat Arms Earplugs lawsuits and liabilities related to PFAS "forever chemicals".

πŸ₯ The April 2024 spin-off of Solventum ended 3M's long aristocrat streak but brought a dividend reset.

πŸ“Š AT&T is now refocusing on converged 5G and fiber, including the closing of its Lumen Mass Markets acquisition in February 2026.

πŸš€ 3M new CEO William Brown has achieved four straight EPS beats as part of the eXcellence turnaround program.

πŸ” Reinvested dividends would have improved AT&T's decade returns but neither stock matches the S&P 500 growth over the period.

πŸ’Ό Current analysts suggest AT&T today offers a choice for income and stability with a 4.24% yield and $45 billion return commitment.

πŸ“ˆ Investors might want to avoid AT&T if rising leverage from the $23 billion EchoStar spectrum deal exceeds management's comfort zone.

🎯 3M looks attractive to those who trust in CEO Brown's ability to expand margins, with guidance of $8.50 to $8.70 EPS for 2026.

⚠️ Remaining risks for 3M include $10.3 billion in residual PFAS settlement obligations and potential new charges from Combat Arms liabilities.

πŸ” The verdict concludes that AT&T's risk/reward profile is tighter and more visible compared to 3M's higher variance.

πŸ† The article emphasizes that Aristocrat status describes the past and neither company owes long-term holders a guaranteed comeback.

Bullish Signals
  • 3M grew a $1,000 investment into $1,435 over 10 years as its turnaround gains traction.
  • New CEO William Brown's 3M eXcellence turnaround has produced four straight EPS beats.
  • 3M offers 2026 adjusted EPS guidance of $8.50 to $8.70 with PFAS manufacturing finally exited.
  • AT&T posted Q1 2026 earnings of $31.51 billion in revenue and $0.57 adjusted EPS.
  • AT&T has committed to a $45 billion shareholder return through 2028, providing significant cash returns.
  • AT&T currently offers a 4.24% yield at an attractive 8 P/E valuation ratio.
Risk Factors
  • Both AT&T (T) and 3M (MMM) underperformed the S&P 500's 244% gain over the last decade, highlighting significant long-term lag.
  • AT&T recently cut its quarterly dividend by 46.6%, reducing it from $0.52 to $0.2775 due to a media misstep involving its DirecTV and Time Warner acquisition.
  • 3M's stock has been dragged down for years by mounting liabilities, including Combat Arms Earplugs lawsuits and PFAS 'forever chemicals' issues.
  • The April 2024 spin-off of the healthcare unit Solventum ended 3M's long aristocrat streak and resulted in a dividend reset.
  • AT&T faces a potential negative catalyst if rising leverage from its $23 billion EchoStar spectrum deal pushes net debt past management's comfort zone.
  • 3M retains residual $10.3 billion PFAS settlement obligations which could drag on financial performance.
  • There remains the specific risk that Combat Arms tail liabilities at 3M could turn into fresh charges in the future.
Full Analysis
AT&T (NYSE: T) and 3M (NYSE: MMM), once celebrated as Dividend Aristocrats, have significantly underperformed the S&P 500 over the past decade, transforming from stable retirement portfolio staples into stocks facing substantial headwinds. A $1,000 investment in AT&T ten years ago is now worth $1,598, yet it still trails the S&P 500's remarkable 244% gain during the same period; similarly, a $1,000 stake in 3M grew to $1,435 over a decade as its turnaround gains traction. Both companies lost their aristocrat status following messy corporate breakups and strategic missteps that eroded shareholder value and forced significant changes in capital allocation. AT&T's decline was precipitated by a disastrous media detour involving the acquisition of DirecTV and Time Warner, which culminated in the spin-off of WarnerMedia into Warner Bros. Discovery in April 2022 and a drastic dividend cut from $0.52 to $0.2775, representing a 46.6% reduction. Under CEO John Stankey, the company refocused on converged 5G and fiber, recently closing the Lumen Mass Markets fiber acquisition in February 2026. Despite its recent Q1 2026 earnings report showing $31.51 billion in revenue and $0.57 adjusted EPS, with a commitment to $45 billion in shareholder returns through 2028 and a current yield of 4.24%, investors must weigh the risks of rising leverage from the $23 billion EchoStar spectrum deal against its cash-return story. 3M's fall has been more gradual but equally painful, driven by mounting liabilities from Combat Arms Earplugs lawsuits and PFAS "forever chemicals." The April 2024 spin-off of its healthcare unit Solventum triggered a dividend reset and ended one of the longest aristocrat streaks on record, while New CEO William Brown's eXcellence turnaround has managed to produce four straight EPS beats. With guidance for 2026 adjusted EPS between $8.50 and $8.70 and ongoing efforts to exit PFAS manufacturing, 3M remains a high-variance bet on an industrial turnaround that is not yet complete; however, residual obligations of $10.3 billion in PFAS settlements and potential new charges from tail liabilities serve as cautionary factors for investors. The article concludes that while AT&T presents a risk/reward profile that is tighter and more visible with its high yield and focus on infrastructure, 3M offers an attractive but unfinished turnaround story under Brown's leadership. Neither stock owes long-term holders a full comeback, serving as a lesson that aristocrat status describes the past rather than guaranteeing future performance, especially given how dramatically both have lagged the broader market while requiring patience through significant corporate restructuring periods from 2018 to 2023.