The Estée Lauder Companies Inc.

(New York Stock Exchange)
Back to all articles
Somewhat Bearish -25

What’s Next for the Estée Lauder Cos. After Failed Merger Talks With Puig? - WWD

AI-generated analysis

📉 Merger talks with Puig ended on May 21 due to valuation issues, leading experts to expect a focus on strategy and divestitures rather than new mega-deals in the near term.

💰 CEO Stéphane de La Faverie emphasized that any future M&A must be accretive to growth and profitability, citing the failed Puig deal as an example of financial misalignment.

📉 EL's stock price has fallen from a peak market cap of over $133 billion in January 2022 to approximately $30.62 billion, trading around $84.64 per share.

🔨 The company is restructuring with an estimated final net reduction of 9,000 to 10,000 positions by the end of fiscal 2026, including cuts in point-of-sale roles.

💸 Restructuring charges are currently being tallied between $1.5 billion and $1.7 billion, with approval expected by the end of this month.

📊 Overall net sales decreased 3% to $14.7 billion last year, though fragrance was an outlier with 10% growth while skin care and makeup remained flat.

🛍️ MAC Cosmetics entered Sephora U.S. for the first time in February, contributing to a 250 basis point market share gain in lip gloss for the brand.

🏷️ Too Faced, Smashbox, and Dr. Jart+ are reportedly under consideration for divestiture, with final bids currently being evaluated by interested parties.

🧴 The 'Beauty Reimagined' strategy aims to restore sustainable sales growth and achieve a double-digit adjusted operating margin over the next few years.

🌍 EL is expanding into high-growth channels like TikTok Shop and Amazon to diversify its offering beyond traditional department stores.

⚔️ L'Oréal remains a major competitor, having strengthened its prestige fragrance portfolio with YSL Beauty leading sales in April.

🤝 Unilever merger speculation persists but is considered unlikely in the near term due to the pending completion of Unilever's food deal with McCormick.

Bullish Signals
  • Fragrance sales grew by 10% in the third quarter, serving as a bright spot amidst flat performance in skin care and makeup categories.
  • The MAC brand achieved significant growth after entering Sephora U.S., gaining 250 basis points of market share in lip gloss and close to triple digits in total lip sales.
  • CEO Stéphane de La Faverie has successfully reinvigorated retail efforts and put brands back into culture, hiring high-profile ambassadors like Doja Cat and Kris Jenner.
  • The company is actively exploring divestitures of non-core brands like Too Faced and Smashbox, which could free up cash for future strategic moves.
  • Recent quarterly beats have been driven by margin recovery and the execution of the 'Beauty Reimagined' program.
  • EL continues to look at fragrance acquisition opportunities that are accretive to growth and profitability, maintaining an open but disciplined M&A stance.
Risk Factors
  • Overall net sales decreased 3% to $14.7 billion last year, with a specific decline of 3% in Americas sales totaling $4.4 billion.
  • Skin care, makeup, and hair care sales were flat in the third quarter of fiscal 2026, indicating stagnation in core business segments.
  • The stock price has collapsed from a peak market cap of over $133 billion to approximately $30.62 billion, reflecting significant investor concern.
  • EL lacks a broad presence in prestige fragrances compared to major competitors like L'Oréal, whose YSL Beauty brand dominated top fragrance sales in April.
  • Restructuring involves a substantial net reduction of 9,000 to 10,000 positions, with over 70% of cuts targeting point-of-sale demonstration roles.
  • Divestiture processes for brands like Too Faced and Smashbox are described as complex, potentially delaying realization of value.
  • The company faces a competitive market share war with L'Oréal, which recently entered a joint venture with Kering to strengthen its position.
Full Analysis
The Estée Lauder Cos. (EL) is shifting its strategic focus following the termination of merger talks with Puig, which ended on May 21 due to valuation disagreements. CEO Stéphane de La Faverie confirmed that while the portfolio complementarity was interesting, the deal did not meet financial criteria for accretive growth and profitability. Consequently, the company is expected to prioritize repairing investor relations, boosting stock performance, and executing divestitures of non-core brands rather than pursuing immediate multibillion-dollar mergers. Under its 'Beauty Reimagined' strategy unveiled in February 2025, EL aims to restore sustainable sales growth and achieve a solid double-digit adjusted operating margin. The company is restructuring operations with an estimated final net reduction of 9,000 to 10,000 positions by the end of fiscal 2026, up from previous estimates. Restructuring charges are currently being tallied between $1.5 billion and $1.7 billion, with decisions on these cuts expected to be approved by the end of the current month. Financially, EL faces headwinds as its stock trades around $84.64, down significantly from its January 2022 peak, and overall net sales decreased 3% to $14.7 billion in the most recent fiscal year. While fragrance sales grew by 10%, skin care, makeup, and hair care remained flat in the third quarter of fiscal 2026. The company is also navigating a competitive landscape where L'Oréal has strengthened its position, particularly in prestige fragrances, prompting EL to focus on revitalizing key brands like MAC and expanding into high-growth channels such as TikTok Shop. Management is actively assessing the brand portfolio for potential divestitures, with Too Faced, Smashbox, and Dr. Jart+ reportedly under consideration for sale. Sources indicate that final bids are in for these brands, potentially completing within weeks. While M&A remains a long-term possibility, particularly in the fragrance sector where EL lacks broad presence compared to competitors, immediate large-scale acquisitions are unlikely without clear financial accretion.