TSLA Inc.

NASDAQ
Back to all articles
Somewhat Bearish -45

Tesla stock tumbles: why a SpaceX takeover may be impossible to pull off

📉 Tesla shares fell 0.9% to $391.06 while SpaceX dropped 3.1% to $131.11, trading below its IPO price.

🧮 An all-stock takeover would likely dilute SpaceX shareholders by roughly 25%, requiring a massive new share issuance.

💸 Analyst Gary Black estimates the combined entity could erase $750 billion in equity value without major synergies.

⚖️ Elon Musk controls 82% of SpaceX voting power, creating a related-party conflict that complicates fiduciary duties.

🤝 Tesla holds a 1% stake in SpaceX via a $2 billion investment and generates $87M quarterly revenue from SpaceX purchases.

🚀 The article suggests the market is pricing in takeover feasibility issues as SpaceX's equity purchasing power declines.

📊 Polymarket data indicates investor skepticism regarding the structural viability of an all-stock merger.

Bullish Signals
  • Tesla and SpaceX have established significant financial interconnectivity, with Tesla investing $2 billion in SpaceX and generating $87 million in revenue from SpaceX purchases.
  • The companies possess strong industrial arguments for closer collaboration across energy storage and computing sectors despite the takeover skepticism.
Risk Factors
  • SpaceX trading below its IPO price reduces its equity purchasing power, making a stock-based acquisition of Tesla increasingly difficult to justify.
  • An all-stock deal would dilute SpaceX shareholders by approximately 25%, potentially destroying $750 billion in combined equity value without substantial synergies.
  • Elon Musk's dual control over both companies creates a related-party conflict that triggers intense scrutiny from independent directors and minority shareholders.
  • The market is increasingly skeptical of the takeover feasibility, causing Tesla to trade as a standalone EV risk asset rather than a takeover beneficiary.
Full Analysis
Tesla shares declined further on Thursday as investors grew skeptical about the feasibility of a potential takeover by SpaceX, with Tesla stock falling 0.9% to $391.06 and SpaceX dropping 3.1% to $131.11, trading below its IPO price. Analyst Gary Black of The Future Fund argues that an all-stock acquisition would require SpaceX to issue a massive block of new shares, potentially diluting existing shareholders by approximately 25%. He warns that at current valuations, such a deal could destroy roughly $750 billion in equity value unless significant synergies are realized. The article highlights governance concerns regarding Elon Musk's control over both entities, noting that while he holds majority voting power in SpaceX, the board still owes fiduciary duties to minority shareholders. This creates a related-party conflict where independent scrutiny of the exchange ratio and valuation assumptions becomes critical. Despite these takeover hurdles, Tesla and SpaceX have deepening financial ties, including a $2 billion investment by Tesla in SpaceX stock and $87 million in revenue from SpaceX purchases of Megapack products, suggesting that operational collaboration may continue even if a merger is unlikely.