Micron Technology, Inc.

NASDAQ Global Select
Back to all articles
Slightly Bullish +25

Micron stock: why 85% margins aren’t enough to stop the sell-off

📊 Micron reported record fiscal Q3 revenue of $41.46 billion with non-GAAP gross margins reaching 84.9%, up from 74.9% in the prior quarter.

💰 Operating cash flow hit $25.39 billion, while adjusted free cash flow reached $18.3 billion, highlighting strong liquidity.

📉 The stock closed at $868.52, trading about 31% below its June high despite the exceptional earnings beat.

🔮 Management forecasts gross margins to rise further to approximately 86% in fiscal Q4 with revenue approaching $50 billion.

⚠️ Citi analyst Atif Malik cut his price target to $1,150, anticipating DRAM and NAND pricing momentum will cool next year.

🤝 Strategic customer agreements covering ~20% of volume are designed to dampen margin volatility and improve revenue visibility.

💻 UBS expects HBM average selling prices to rise 79% year-over-year, with HBM4 and HBM4E pricing running stronger than prior expectations.

🔒 Supply constraints are expected to persist through at least 2027, with meaningful new capacity unlikely until 2028.

🧠 The market debate has shifted from demand collapse to the duration of elevated profitability and margin sustainability.

🚀 Some analysts argue AI is making today's shortage more severe than past memory cycles, supporting a re-rating of valuation.

Bullish Signals
  • Record fiscal Q3 revenue of $41.46 billion demonstrates peak-like demand levels in the memory sector.
  • Non-GAAP gross margin expansion to 84.9% indicates strong pricing power and operational efficiency.
  • Operating cash flow of $25.39 billion provides substantial flexibility for R&D, M&A, or share buybacks.
  • Strategic customer agreements covering ~20% of volume reduce historical revenue volatility associated with memory cycles.
  • UBS projects HBM average selling prices to rise 79% year-over-year, signaling robust demand for AI memory.
  • Management guidance expects gross margins to increase further to ~86% in Q4, reinforcing peak profitability.
  • Mizuho and Deutsche Bank analysts see tight supply conditions sustaining margins above 80% through 2027.
  • AI-driven demand is described as more severe than past cycles, suggesting a structural shift in memory economics.
Risk Factors
  • Citi analyst Atif Malik lowered the price target to $1,150, citing expectations that DRAM and NAND pricing will cool next year.
  • Investors question how much of today's extraordinary 85% profitability can survive the next phase of the cycle.
  • The stock trades roughly 31% below its June high, reflecting market skepticism about margin sustainability.
  • Analysts warn that HBM and NAND pricing could roll over faster than expected, pushing gross margins back toward the mid-70% range.
  • Citi expects profitability to normalize as the cyclical peak thesis is confirmed by potential demand shifts.
Full Analysis
Analysts are debating whether Micron Technology's (MU) recent stock sell-off is justified despite the company posting record-breaking financial results in fiscal Q3. The chipmaker reported a non-GAAP gross margin of 84.9%, up significantly from the previous quarter and year-ago period, alongside record revenue of $41.46 billion. Operating margins hit 81.2% with strong cash flows, leading some investors to argue that the market is undervaluing the company by applying an outdated cyclical framework to a business whose economics are becoming more durable. However, the primary concern driving the stock down remains investor skepticism about the sustainability of these ultra-high margins as the memory cycle potentially normalizes. While management expects gross margins to rise further to approximately 86% in Q4 with revenue nearing $50 billion, analysts like Citi's Atif Malik have lowered price targets, anticipating that DRAM and NAND pricing momentum will cool next year. This divergence between current exceptional profitability and future expectations creates a valuation gap where the stock trades roughly 31% below its June highs. Strategic factors are emerging that could alter this outlook, specifically regarding High-Bandwidth Memory (HBM) demand and supply constraints. UBS analysts note that HBM pricing is running even stronger than expected, with average selling prices projected to rise 79% year-over-year. Additionally, Micron's multiyear strategic customer agreements covering about 20% of volume aim to reduce historical volatility. The market debate has shifted from demand collapse to the duration of elevated profitability, with some analysts like Mizuho and Deutsche Bank predicting tight supply conditions could sustain margins above 80% through at least 2027. Ultimately, Micron's stock performance hinges on whether investors accept that AI-driven demand is transforming memory economics into a more software-like durability or if the cyclical peak thesis prevails. If HBM stays tight and supply remains constrained until new capacity arrives in 2028, the current valuation framework may be wrong, allowing for a potential re-rating upward. Conversely, if pricing rolls over faster than expected, margins could revert to the mid-70% range, confirming the sell-off as a rational correction based on anticipated normalization.