Micron Technology, Inc.

NASDAQ Global Select
Back to all articles
Bullish +65

Nvidia Stock vs. Micron Stock: Wall Street Says Buy One and Sell the Other - The Globe and Mail

📊 Wall Street consensus suggests buying Nvidia (44% upside) and selling Micron (8% downside) based on current valuations.

💻 Nvidia holds nearly 90% of AI accelerator sales and dominates the market with its Grace Blackwell superchip architecture.

🚀 Nvidia reported Q1 revenue of $81.6 billion, an 85% increase driven by strong demand for data center compute products.

🔮 Nvidia's next-generation Vera Rubin chip is expected to be 10 times more efficient than Grace Blackwell and shipping later this year.

📈 Analysts forecast Nvidia's adjusted earnings will grow at 43% annually through fiscal 2029, supporting its current valuation.

💾 Micron reported Q2 sales of $23.8 billion, a 196% increase driven by consumer and enterprise data center markets.

⚠️ Micron lacks a durable economic moat because memory chips are commodities with interchangeable products from competitors.

📉 Samsung and SK Hynix have gained market share at Micron's expense due to greater production capacity advantages.

📅 Wall Street expects the memory chip boom to peak in 2028, implying sharp sales drops in 2029.

💰 Micron trades at 48 times earnings, which analysts consider expensive compared to Nvidia's 32 times earnings.

🏢 Micron operates across four end markets: consumer devices, automotive systems, enterprise data centers, and cloud hyperscalers.

📉 Analysts forecast Micron's adjusted earnings will grow at only 13% annually through fiscal 2029 due to cyclical headwinds.

Bullish Signals
  • Nvidia dominates the AI accelerator market with nearly 90% share and its Grace Blackwell superchip is the fastest and most efficient on the market.
  • Nvidia reported solid Q1 financial results with revenue rising 85% to $81.6 billion due to strong demand for data center products.
  • Nvidia's non-GAAP net income increased 140% to $1.87 per diluted share, demonstrating strong profitability growth.
  • The upcoming Vera Rubin superchip is projected to be 10 times more efficient than Grace Blackwell and is already off to a tremendous start.
  • Nvidia trades at 32 times earnings, which represents its cheapest valuation in seven years despite high growth expectations.
  • The AI infrastructure market is forecast to hit $4 trillion by 2030, providing Nvidia with a long runway for continued growth.
  • Analysts estimate Nvidia's adjusted earnings will increase at 43% annually through fiscal 2029, supporting its current stock price.
Risk Factors
  • Micron lacks a durable economic moat because memory chips are commodities, meaning products from different manufacturers are mostly interchangeable.
  • Industry leaders Samsung and SK Hynix have gained market share at Micron's expense in the most recent quarter due to greater production capacity.
  • The memory chip industry historically alternates between boom and bust cycles, with Wall Street expecting the current boom to peak in 2028.
  • Analysts forecast that sales will drop sharply in 2029 as the cycle turns, creating a significant headwind for Micron's future earnings.
  • Micron's adjusted earnings are forecast to increase at only 13% annually through fiscal 2029, which is significantly lower than Nvidia's projected growth.
  • Micron currently trades at 48 times earnings, which analysts consider quite expensive given the expected cyclical downturn and slower growth outlook.
Full Analysis
Wall Street analysts are divided on the relative value of semiconductor giants Nvidia and Micron, with a consensus suggesting investors should buy Nvidia while selling Micron. While both companies have been massive winners in the AI infrastructure build-out since January 2023, adding over 1,300% to their stock prices respectively, current valuations differ significantly based on analyst targets. Nvidia is viewed as undervalued with a median target price of $300 implying 44% upside. The company maintains a dominant market position with nearly 90% share in AI accelerators and has reinforced its lead with the Grace Blackwell superchip. Strong financial results, including an 85% revenue rise to $81.6 billion, and upcoming Vera Rubin chips are driving expectations for 43% annual earnings growth through fiscal 2029. In contrast, Micron faces a median target price of $949, implying 8% downside from its current level. Although the company recently crushed estimates with sales up 196%, it lacks a durable economic moat as memory chips are commodities. Industry leaders Samsung and SK Hynix have gained market share at Micron's expense due to superior production capacity, and Wall Street expects the current boom to peak in 2028. The article concludes that Nvidia's valuation of 32 times earnings is attractive compared to Micron's 48 times earnings. While Micron's adjusted earnings are forecast to grow at 13% annually, the commodity nature of its products and the looming cyclical downturn in 2029 make it appear overvalued relative to Nvidia's long runway and dominant position.