MSCI Inc.

New York Stock Exchange
Back to all articles
Slightly Bearish -20

MSCI keeps South Korea as emerging market, delays Indonesia review amid downgrade risk - CNBC

📉 MSCI kept South Korea in the emerging-markets category, rejecting hopes for inclusion on the Developed Markets watchlist.

🚧 Limited convertibility of the Korean won and a rigid investor identification system remain key barriers to reclassification.

⏳ MSCI extended Indonesia's review until November after freezing its stocks in January due to investability concerns.

⚠️ MSCI warned it will consider downgrading Indonesia to frontier-market status if current reforms prove insufficient.

📅 South Korea plans to launch 24-hour trading in the dollar-won spot market starting July 6.

💰 Analysts suggest an MSCI upgrade could resolve the 'Korea discount,' addressing lower valuations compared to global peers.

🗣️ Bank of America economist Benson Wu stated that achieving developed-market status will be a multi-year process.

🏛️ South Korea's Finance Ministry confirmed reforms are ongoing but need more time to show results for watchlist inclusion.

Bullish Signals
  • South Korea is preparing to launch 24-hour trading in the dollar-won spot market on July 6, signaling a commitment to opening its foreign exchange market to overseas investors.
  • MSCI acknowledged measures announced by South Korean authorities to address convertibility and investment restrictions, indicating that some progress has been made despite the current classification.
Risk Factors
  • MSCI explicitly stated that underlying issues regarding South Korea's currency convertibility and investor identification systems have not been fully resolved by investors.
  • Indonesia's stocks were frozen in MSCI indexes in January due to investability concerns, with a warning of a potential downgrade to frontier-market status if reforms fail.
  • South Korea was not added to the Developed Markets watchlist because some reforms are still underway and completed measures need more time to demonstrate results.
Full Analysis
Index provider MSCI has maintained South Korea's classification as an emerging market following its latest review, effectively rejecting Seoul's hopes for inclusion on the Developed Markets watchlist. The decision stems from persistent barriers regarding the convertibility of the Korean won in offshore markets and a rigid investor identification system that limits off-exchange transactions and investment products. Concurrently, MSCI extended its assessment of Indonesia's market status until November after raising concerns about accessibility earlier this year. The provider froze Indonesian stocks in its indexes in January due to investability issues and warned that if current reforms prove insufficient, it will consider downgrading the country to frontier-market status. South Korean authorities acknowledge that while some measures are underway, investors have communicated that underlying structural issues remain unresolved. Analysts note that an upgrade could help resolve the 'Korea discount,' a phenomenon where South Korean stocks trade at lower valuations than global peers, but experts suggest this transition will be a multi-year process rather than an immediate outcome. To address these concerns, Seoul plans to launch 24-hour trading in the dollar-won spot market on July 6 as a step toward opening its foreign exchange market. However, Bank of America economist Benson Wu indicates that longer trading hours alone may not be sufficient to unlock an MSCI upgrade without further comprehensive reforms to currency hedging and market infrastructure.