McDonald's Corporation

New York Stock Exchange
Back to all articles
Neutral 0

McDonald's is taking away your fountain machine. Burger King not so much.

🥤 McDonald's is officially phasing out self-service fountain machines in its US dining rooms by 2032.

🏛️ Burger King will not remove its machines, noting that consumers want to mix their own drinks and refill them themselves.

🤖 Many Burger King locations feature Coca-Cola Freestyle touchscreen machines for customizing soda flavors.

📉 McDonald's cited a shift in ordering platforms, which now account for about 40% of domestic sales, as a driver for the change.

🧹 The move aims to improve consistency across all channels, streamline operations, and reduce maintenance costs.

💧 McDonald's CFO Ian Borden indicated that free refills will "probably" continue despite removing the machines.

⏳ Consumer reaction to the removal of fountain machines has not yet impacted McDonald's financial results.

🔴 Burger King reported a 5.8% same-store sales increase in the first quarter, beating industry expectations.

🥓 McDonald's posted a 3.9% same-store sales increase in the same period, trailing Burger King's performance.

🤝 Burger King President Tom Curtis described the competition as a "zero-sum game" where better experiences drive growth.

Bullish Signals
  • Burger King achieved a same-store sales increase of 5.8% in the first quarter, significantly outperforming the quick-service restaurant industry.
  • Burger King's US business growth of 5.8% bested McDonald's, which posted a same-store sales increase of 3.9% in the same period.
  • Burger King maintains its self-service Freestyle machines, aligning with consumer demand for mixing and refilling beverages while competitors phase them out.
  • McDonald's strategic shift to phasing out fountain machines targets high maintenance and repair costs associated with customer-facing machines, potentially improving operational margins.
  • McDonald's expects about 40% of domestic sales to come from delivery, kiosks, and drive-through channels, aligning its beverage strategy with these high-growth ordering platforms.
Risk Factors
  • McDonald's is phasing out its self-service fountain machines with a completion date targeted for 2032, ending a decades-old fast food tradition.
  • The removal of fountain machines could negatively impact customer experience and convenience, potentially driving customers to competitors like Burger King.
  • McDonald's US same-store sales increased only 3.9% in the first quarter, which underperformed compared to Burger King's 5.8% growth in the same period.
  • Burger King has already achieved a significant market advantage, with its US chain delivering results that outperformed the quick-service restaurant industry by more than five points.
  • The shift away from fountain machines may limit McDonald's ability to compete on beverage variety and customization compared to Burger King's Coca-Cola Freestyle options.
  • CFO Ian Borden indicated only a 'probably' free refill continuation, introducing uncertainty regarding future service offerings that could affect customer retention.
Full Analysis
McDonald's is officially ending its self-service fountain machines in U.S. dining rooms by 2032, aiming to create a consistent experience across kiosks, delivery, drive-thru, and in-store operations which account for about 40% of domestic sales. This strategic shift, announced in September 2023, is designed to streamline operations, control beverage portions, enhance cleanliness, and eliminate the high maintenance costs associated with customer-facing machines. McDonald's CFO Ian Borden indicated that while the machines are being removed, the company likely will continue to offer free refills for customers. In contrast, Burger King US and Canada President Tom Curtis stated that his chain is not yet removing its fountain machines because consumer demand remains for self-mixing drinks and refills. Many Burger King locations currently feature Coca-Cola Freestyle machines allowing diners to customize their beverages. This approach has yielded financial results, with Restaurant Brands International reporting a 5.8% same-store sales increase for the Burger King US chain in the first quarter, outperforming the quick-service restaurant industry and exceeding McDonald's U.S. same-store sales growth of 3.9% during the same period. Analysts note that this represents a zero-sum game where offering a better core product and experience can drive growth in a non-expanding category.