Costco Wholesale Corporation

NASDAQ Global Select
Back to all articles
Somewhat Bullish +50

Costco vs. McDonald's: Which Dividend Stock Is a Better Buy?

AI-generated analysis

📉 McDonald's CEO warned that the consumer environment may be deteriorating further, expressing concern that conditions are not improving.

🛒 Costco recently raised its quarterly dividend by 13%, increasing the payout from $1.30 to $1.47 per share.

🔺 This marks the company's 22nd consecutive annual dividend increase, highlighting a strong commitment to shareholder returns.

📈 Costco reported April net sales rising 13% year-over-year to approximately $24 billion, excluding seasonal factors and gas price impacts.

💰 Membership fee income grew 13.6% in the fiscal second quarter, with executive memberships climbing 9.5% to over 40 million.

📉 Costco's stock trades at roughly 47 times forward earnings, which reflects a high valuation despite its low headline yield of 0.6%.

📊 The warehouse club's worldwide membership renewal rate decreased slightly to 89.7% in fiscal Q2 compared to 90.5% the prior year.

🍔 McDonald's offers a more conventional dividend yield of 2.6% with a quarterly payout of $1.86 per share.

📉 McDonald's revenue grew 4% in constant currencies for the first quarter, with global comparable sales rising only 3.8%.

📉 The burger giant trades at about 23 times forward earnings, which is near its long-run historical average.

💸 McDonald's management reaffirmed a capital spending plan of $3.7 billion to $3.9 billion for 2026 to support new restaurant openings.

🏢 Analysts suggest Costco may be the better long-term pick due to substantially higher business momentum and comparable sales growth compared to McDonald's.

⚠️ McDonald's faces potential near-term pressure on free cash flow as it invests in expanding its restaurant footprint.

📉 Some analysts excluded Costco from their top 10 stock lists, though they acknowledge its strong dividend history.

🤖 Both companies share similarities as blue-chip consumer giants with global footprints and significant pricing power in their respective markets.

Bullish Signals
  • Costco recently raised its dividend by 13%, marking its 22nd consecutive annual increase, which demonstrates a strong commitment to shareholder returns.
  • April net sales surged 13% year over year to approximately $24 billion, highlighting robust demand and growth momentum.
  • Total comparable sales climbed 11.6% during the four-week period, with an underlying growth of 7.8% even after adjusting for gasoline prices and calendar effects.
  • Net sales for the first 35 weeks of fiscal 2026 reached $197.18 billion, representing a strong 9.5% year-over-year increase.
  • Net income climbed nearly 14% to $2.04 billion in the fiscal second quarter ended Feb. 15, 2026.
  • Membership fee income rose 13.6% in the quarter, while paid executive memberships increased by 9.5% to more than 40 million members.
  • McDonald's executed a meaningful capital return profile by buying back 1.3 million shares for $393 million in the quarter.
  • Despite global challenges, McDonald's reported that U.S. comparable sales were up 3.9%, driven by positive check growth.
Risk Factors
  • McDonald's CEO explicitly warned that the consumer environment may be getting worse, citing that conditions are 'certainly not improving' and potentially deteriorating further.
  • The worldwide membership renewal rate for Costco fell to 89.7% in fiscal Q2, a decline from 90.5% in the same quarter of 2025.
  • McDonald's US comparable sales growth of only 3.9% pales in comparison to Costco's significantly higher acceleration.
  • Management at McDonald's reaffirmed a substantial capital spending plan of $3.7 billion to $3.9 billion for 2026, which may put near-term pressure on free cash flow.
  • McDonald's non-GAAP earnings per share growth was minimal, rising just 1% in constant currencies during the first quarter.
  • The Motley Fool Stock Advisor team has identified 10 stocks they believe are better buys than Costco Wholesale.
  • Costco's stock valuation is described as 'unforgiving,' trading at roughly 47 times forward earnings.
Full Analysis
Costco Wholesale (NASDAQ: COST) recently increased its quarterly dividend by 13%, raising the payout from $1.30 to $1.47 per share, which marks the 22nd consecutive year of annual increases. Despite a headline yield of only 0.6%, the retailer shows strong business momentum with April net sales rising 13% year over year to approximately $24 billion and total comparable sales climbing 11.6% in the four-week period. After adjusting for gas price changes, foreign exchange swings, and an extra Easter shopping day, comparable sales still grew 7.8%, accelerating from the previous quarter's 6.2%. For the fiscal year ending February 2026, net sales reached $197.18 billion, up 9.5%, while net income climbed nearly 14% to $2.04 billion, driven largely by membership fee income which rose 13.6% as paid executive memberships surpassed 40 million with a renewal rate of 89.7%. In contrast, McDonald's (NYSE: MCD) offers a higher conventional yield of 2.6% and trades at a lower multiple relative to earnings compared to Costco. However, its growth trajectory is slower, with constant currency revenue growing just 4% in the first quarter and global comparable sales up 3.8%, while its CEO warned that the consumer environment may be getting worse rather than improving. McDonald's maintained capital return through dividends and share buybacks, purchasing 1.3 million shares for $393 million in the quarter, but faces pressure on free cash flow due to a planned capital spending budget of $3.7 billion to $3.9 billion to open over 2,000 new restaurants through 2026. The analysis concludes that while McDonald's provides steadier near-term cash returns and a more attractive yield at roughly 23 times forward earnings, Costco's superior comparable sales growth rate—nearly double that of McDonald's—and consistent financial expansion make it the preferable long-term dividend choice despite its higher valuation of approximately 47 times forward earnings and lower immediate yield. The article notes that membership fee revenue provides a dependable recurring income stream for Costco, whereas McDonald's growth depends more heavily on check averages in a potentially weakening consumer landscape. The content is a substantive investment analysis comparing the business fundamentals, financial metrics, dividend histories, and management commentary of two major consumer staples companies, with specific data points including sales figures, growth rates, dividend amounts, share counts, and earnings per share clearly articulated.