American Express Company

New York Stock Exchange
Back to all articles
Somewhat Bullish +50

Visa (V) vs American Express (AXP): Which is a Better Stock to Buy

Market commentary AI-generated analysis

📊 American Express trades at a significant discount to Visa, with a price-to-earnings ratio of roughly 18x compared to Visa's 31x multiple.

🚀 Amex demonstrated faster earnings growth recently, with earnings per share rising nearly 16% over the past year.

💰 American Express pays a noticeably larger dividend than Visa, offering higher income potential to shareholders.

⚠️ As a closed-loop lender, Amex carries direct consumer credit risk that impacts its bottom line more severely than Visa's toll-road model.

📅 Investors are advised to watch for Amex's credit provisions when the company reports earnings on October 23.

🛡️ Visa is expanding its technology stack with an agreement to acquire fraud detection firm BioCatch for $2.4 billion in August.

👥 American Express benefits from a cardholder base that skews affluent, historically providing resilience during economic downturns.

Bullish Signals
  • American Express trades at a valuation discount of roughly half compared to Visa, offering investors a lower entry price relative to earnings.
  • The company is growing earnings faster than its competitor, with EPS increasing nearly 16% in the most recent period.
  • Amex offers a larger dividend yield than Visa, providing an attractive income component for shareholders.
  • The company's affluent cardholder base has historically softened the impact of economic downturns on credit losses.
Risk Factors
  • American Express carries significant consumer credit risk because it issues cards and lends its own money, unlike Visa which acts as a processor.
  • The company's lower valuation multiple reflects market concerns that a weakening consumer economy will hit Amex directly through loan defaults.
Full Analysis
The article compares Visa Inc. (NYSE: V) and American Express Company (NYSE: AXP), arguing that while Visa is the superior business model with a 'toll road' structure, American Express offers better value for investors today. Amex trades at approximately 18 times past year's earnings compared to Visa's 31x multiple, despite Visa generating roughly $22 billion in profit from $44 billion in revenue versus Amex's $11 billion profit from $72 billion. American Express is highlighted for its faster earnings growth, with EPS rising nearly 16% recently, and a larger dividend yield. The company carries consumer credit risk as it issues cards and lends money, which explains its lower valuation multiple. Analysts note that if Amex's credit provisions remain contained in the upcoming October 23 report, the current discount to Visa becomes difficult to justify. Visa continues to expand into fraud prevention and stablecoin infrastructure, having agreed to acquire BioCatch for $2.4 billion in August, though the deal has not yet closed. Conversely, Amex benefits from an affluent cardholder base that historically softens the blow of economic downturns. The author concludes that American Express is the better buy for investors willing to accept consumer credit risk in exchange for a lower valuation and higher dividend.